Catalog
affaan-m/scientific-thinking-literature-review

affaan-m

scientific-thinking-literature-review

Systematic literature-review workflow for academic, biomedical, technical, and scientific topics, including search planning, source screening, synthesis, citation checks, and evidence logging. Use when the task is to find, screen, synthesize, and cite a body of academic or technical literature.

NewUpdated Nov 17, 2026

Literature Review

Use this skill when the task is to find, screen, synthesize, and cite a body of academic or technical literature.

When to Use

  • Building a systematic, scoping, or narrative literature review.
  • Synthesizing the state of the art for a research question.
  • Finding gaps, contradictions, or future-work directions.
  • Preparing citation-backed background sections for papers or reports.
  • Comparing evidence across peer-reviewed papers, preprints, patents, and technical reports.

Review Types

  • Narrative review: broad synthesis; useful for orientation.
  • Scoping review: maps concepts, methods, and evidence gaps.
  • Systematic review: predefined protocol, reproducible search, explicit screening and exclusion.
  • Meta-analysis: systematic review plus quantitative effect aggregation.

Ask the user which level of rigor is needed. If unspecified, default to a scoping review for exploratory work and a systematic review for publication or clinical claims.

Workflow

1. Define the Question

Convert the prompt into a searchable research question.

For clinical or biomedical work, use PICO:

  • Population
  • Intervention or exposure
  • Comparator
  • Outcome

For technical work, use:

  • system or domain
  • method or intervention
  • comparison baseline
  • evaluation metric

Create a search protocol before collecting sources:

  • databases to search
  • date range
  • languages
  • publication types
  • inclusion criteria
  • exclusion criteria
  • exact search strings

Minimum useful database set:

  • PubMed for biomedical and life-sciences literature.
  • arXiv for CS, math, physics, quantitative biology, and preprints.
  • OpenAlex, Semantic Scholar or Crossref for broad academic discovery across fields.
  • Domain-specific sources when relevant, such as clinical-trial registries, patent databases, standards bodies, or official technical docs.

3. Search and Log Evidence

Keep a search log that makes the review reproducible:

| Database | Date searched | Query | Filters | Results | Export |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | ---: | --- |
| PubMed | 2026-05-11 | `("CRISPR"[tiab] OR "Cas9"[tiab]) AND "sickle cell"[tiab]` | 2020:2026, English | 86 | PMID list |
| arXiv | 2026-05-11 | `CRISPR sickle cell gene editing` | q-bio, 2020:2026 | 9 | BibTeX |

Save raw IDs, URLs, DOIs, abstracts, and notes separately from the final prose.

4. Deduplicate

Deduplicate in this order:

  1. DOI
  2. PMID or arXiv ID
  3. exact title
  4. normalized title plus first author and year

Record how many duplicates were removed.

5. Screen Sources

Screen in stages:

  1. title
  2. abstract
  3. full text

For systematic work, record exclusion reasons:

  • wrong population
  • wrong intervention
  • wrong outcome
  • not primary research
  • duplicate
  • unavailable full text
  • outside date range

6. Extract Data

Use a structured extraction table:

| Study | Design | Population/Data | Method | Comparator | Outcome | Key finding | Limitations |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Author Year | RCT/cohort/review/etc. | sample or corpus | method | baseline | measured outcome | result | caveat |

For technical papers, include dataset, benchmark, metric, baseline, and reproducibility notes.

7. Synthesize

Group evidence by theme rather than summarizing papers one by one.

Useful synthesis lenses:

  • strongest evidence
  • conflicting evidence
  • methodological weaknesses
  • population or dataset limits
  • recency and replication
  • practical implications
  • unanswered questions

Separate claims by confidence:

  • High confidence: replicated, high-quality evidence across sources.
  • Medium confidence: plausible but limited by sample, method, or recency.
  • Low confidence: early, speculative, single-source, or weakly measured.

8. Verify Citations

Before finalizing:

  • verify DOI, PMID, arXiv ID, or official URL
  • check author names and publication year
  • do not cite a paper for a claim it does not make
  • mark preprints as preprints
  • distinguish reviews from primary evidence

Output Template

# Literature Review: <Topic>

Generated: <date>
Review type: <narrative | scoping | systematic | meta-analysis>
Search window: <dates>
Databases: <list>

## Research Question

## Search Strategy

## Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria

## Evidence Summary

## Thematic Synthesis

## Gaps and Limitations

## References

## Search Log

Pitfalls

  • Do not treat search snippets as evidence.
  • Do not mix preprints, reviews, and primary studies without labeling them.
  • Do not omit negative or conflicting findings.
  • Do not claim systematic-review rigor without a reproducible protocol.
  • Do not use a single database for a broad claim unless the scope is explicitly limited to that database.
Files1
1 files · 1.0 KB

Select a file to preview

Overall Score

88/100

Grade

A

Excellent

Grades are signals, not a certification. Always review a skill yourself before use.

Safety

95

Quality

85

Clarity

88

Completeness

82

Summary

A systematic literature-review workflow skill that guides agents through academic research methodology, including search planning, source screening, evidence synthesis, and citation verification. The skill covers narrative, scoping, systematic, and meta-analysis review types, with structured templates and reproducibility protocols for research documentation.

Detected Capabilities

literature database searchsource screening and deduplicationevidence extraction and synthesiscitation verificationstructured data tabulationsearch protocol documentation

Trigger Keywords

Phrases that agents use to match this skill to user intent.

literature reviewsystematic reviewresearch synthesisevidence synthesiscitation searchacademic researchbiomedical literature

Use Cases

  • Conduct systematic biomedical literature reviews for clinical decision support
  • Map technical research landscape across multiple databases (PubMed, arXiv, OpenAlex)
  • Synthesize conflicting evidence and identify research gaps for publication
  • Prepare evidence-backed background sections for academic papers and reports
  • Screen and extract data from academic sources following reproducible protocols

Quality Notes

  • Clear workflow structure with 8 sequential stages, each with specific outputs and decisions
  • Appropriate handling of review-type selection; defers to user for rigor level and provides sensible defaults (scoping for exploratory, systematic for publication)
  • Comprehensive database recommendations tailored to domain (PubMed for biomedical, arXiv for CS/math, OpenAlex for breadth)
  • Structured deduplication protocol with explicit ordering by confidence (DOI > PMID > title > normalized fields)
  • Explicit guidance on data extraction with example table format for both biomedical (design, population, outcome) and technical (dataset, benchmark, metric) work
  • Synthesis guidance uses evidence-confidence framing (high/medium/low) to avoid false certainty
  • Pitfalls section explicitly warns against common methodology errors (mixing study types without labels, omitting negative findings, claiming rigor without protocol)
  • Reproducibility emphasis throughout — search logs, inclusion/exclusion criteria, deduplication tracking, citation verification checks
  • Output template provided with all required sections for formal review documentation
Model: claude-haiku-4-5-20251001Analyzed: Nov 17, 2026

Reviews

Add this skill to your library to leave a review.

No reviews yet

Be the first to share your experience.

Version History

  1. v1.1

    Content updated

    ✦ AIAdds OpenAlex to recommended literature-discovery sources.

    2026-11-17

    LATEST
  2. v1.0

    2026-09-30

    View This VersionInitial version

Use affaan-m/scientific-thinking-literature-review in your dev environment

Command Palette

Search for a command to run...